高考英语阅读 · 错项拆解

2023 年 全国乙卷

第 22 题

原文(A 篇)

A 篇 PRACTITIONERS

1Jacqueline Felice de Almania (c.1322) highlights the suspicion that women practicing medicine faced. Born to a Jewish family in Florence, she moved to Paris where she worked as a physician and performed surgery. In 1322 she was tried for practicing unlawfully. In spite of the court hearing testimonials (证明) of her ability as a doctor, she was banned from medicine.

2James Barry (c.1789-1865) was born Margaret Bulkley in Ireland but, dressed as a man, she was accepted by Edinburgh University to study medicine. She qualified as a surgeon in 1813, then joined the British Army, serving overseas. Barry retired in 1859, having practiced her entire medical profession living and working as a man.

3Tan Yunxian (1461-1554) was a Chinese physician who learned her skills from her grandparents. Chinese women at the time could not serve apprenticeships (学徒期) with doctors. However, Tan passed the official exam. Tan treated women from all walks of life. In 1511, Tan wrote a book, Sayings of a Female Doctor, describing her life as a physician.

4Rebecca Lee Crumpler (1831-1895) worked as a nurse for eight years before studying in medical college in Boston in 1860. Four years later, she was the first African American woman to receive a medical degree. She moved to Virginia in 1865, where she provided medical care to freed slaves.

第 22 题 · 细节理解

How was Tan Yunxian different from the other practitioners?

定位句

In 1511, Tan wrote a book1511 年,谈允贤写了一本书

为什么选 A 四个人里只有谈允贤写过书,这就是她和别人不同的地方,选 A。

其他选项错在哪

  • B 张冠李戴受审(tried)的是 Jacqueline,不是谈允贤。选项的 trials 正是“审判”。
  • C 原文没说四个人里没有一个当过牙医。
  • D 原文没说谈允贤跟祖父母学医,后来通过了考试,这不等于上过正规学校;原文还说当时女性连学徒都当不了。

词汇:trials 审判;dentist 牙医;practitioners 从业者,这里指行医的人

← 第 21 题第 23 题 →