高考英语阅读 · 错项拆解

2023 年 北京卷

第 34 题

原文(D 篇)

D 篇

1What is life? Like most great questions, this one is easy to ask but difficult to answer. The reason is simple: we know of just one type of life and it’s challenging to do science with a sample size of one. The field of artificial life-called ALife for short — is the systematic attempt to spell out life’s fundamental principles. Many of these practitioners, so-called ALifers, think that somehow making life is the surest way to really understand what life is.

2So far no one has convincingly made artificial life. This track record makes ALife a ripe target for criticism, such as declarations of the field’s doubtful scientific value. Alan Smith, a complexity scientist, is tired of such complaints. Asking about “the point” of ALife might be, well, missing the point entirely, he says. “The existence of a living system is not about the use of anything.” Alan says. “Some people ask me, ‘So what’s the worth of artificial life?’ Do you ever think, ‘What is the worth of your grandmother?’”

3As much as many ALifers hate emphasizing their research’s applications, the attempts to create artificial life could have practical payoffs. Artificial intelligence may be considered ALife’s cousin in that researchers in both fields are enamored by a concept called open-ended evolution (演化). This is the capacity for a system to create essentially endless complexity, to be a sort of “novelty generator”. The only system known to exhibit this is Earth’s biosphere. If the field of ALife manages to reproduce life’s endless “creativity” in some virtual model, those same principles could give rise to truly inventive machines.

4Compared with the developments of Al, advances in ALife are harder to recognize. One reason is that ALife is a field in which the central concept — life itself — is undefined. The lack of agreement among ALifers doesn’t help either. The result is a diverse line of projects that each advance along their unique paths. For better or worse, ALife mirrors the very subject it studies. Its muddled (混乱的) progression is a striking parallel (平行线) to the evolutionary struggles that have shaped Earth biosphere.

5Undefined and uncontrolled, ALife drives its followers to repurpose old ideas and generated novelty. It may be, of course, that these characteristics aren’t in any way surprising or singular. They may apply universally to all acts of evolution. Ultimately ALife may be nothing special. But even this dismissal suggests something:perhaps, just like life itself throughout the universe, the rise of ALife will prove unavoidable.

第 34 题 · 主旨大意

Which would be the best title for the passage?

定位句

For better or worse, ALife mirrors the very subject it studies.不管是好是坏,ALife 本身就像它研究的对象(生命)一样。
the rise of ALife will prove unavoidableALife 的兴起将被证明不可避免

为什么选 D 全文说 ALife 的发展像生命演化一样,各走各的路、混乱地前进,最后也会像生命一样必然兴起。D“生命会演化,创造人工生命的尝试也会演化吗?”最合适,选 D。

其他选项错在哪

  • A 原文没说原文没说 AI 能解决生命没有定义的问题。
  • B 原文没说原文没说 AI 帮助 ALife 发展。
  • C 以偏概全“没有定义”只是第 4 段的一个原因,全文讲的是 ALife 像生命一样演化。

词汇:Undefined 没有定义的;evolve 演化

← 第 33 题